After a long day’s work at a law firm in Nigeria’s capital, Abuja, 35-year-old Comfort Daniel returned to her apartment one cold evening in December 2014 and began to undress for a bath. She was halfway done when she felt a lump on her left breast. A pang of apprehension surged through her. She ran her hand over her breast and the lump became more visible.
But Daniel didn’t go to hospital for screening immediately. Instead she consulted a South African-based physician who visited her church after Sunday service. The physician gave her some drugs for 17,000 naira (£44) and told her that she would have a discharge from her nipple then she would be healed.
Trusting the physician’s assurance, Daniel didn’t visit the hospital for screening. Two weeks after the treatment, a brownish discharge came from her nipple, but she became more uncomfortable. Shortly afterwards she was watching TV when a health programme came on and a doctor advised women to go for screenings whenever they noticed any abnormalities on their breasts. “That was all I needed to go to a hospital in downtown Abuja,” she says.
After several months of travelling between a private clinic and the national hospital in Abuja, and after spending most of her savings on appointments, Daniel finally learned she had cancer in March 2015. “God forbid,” she recalls yelling at the doctors. “Nobody has cancer in my family.”
Daniel was astonished. “I thought cancer was a disease for elderly, more mature people,” she says. “But all of that changed after the doctors told me I had stage two breast cancer. In fact, they even said I’d had the lump on my breast for more than a year.”
Daniel underwent a mastectomy shortly after getting her diagnosis and is now having chemotherapy. She says the healthcare system was inadequate for her needs. “When I wanted to receive initial treatment, I had to visit many hospitals … doctors were either on strike or there was no electricity to power the machines, or they weren’t responding properly. This whole process can be frustrating.”
Project Pink Blue organised a march against cancer in Nigeria last year. Photograph: Wahabi Oluwafemi
Daniel’s experience of trying alternative treatments before approaching doctors is common in Nigeria. Professor Tajudeen Olasinde is a consultant radiation and clinical oncologist at the Ahmadu Bello University Teaching Hospital in Zaria. He says late presentation is a widespread problem. “Around 85% of cancer patients present at advanced stages of their diseases in Nigeria due to poor awareness.”
Even when people do seek treatment, the equipment and facilities needed to treat cancer are not available everywhere. “Most diagnostic and treatment equipment are available in only tertiary health institutions, which are far away from most rural dwellers,” Olasinde says. “Where only one or two radiation treatment mega-voltage machines are functioning optimally at any time, [this] is unacceptable and a national disgrace for a country of 180 million people. At least, the country needs 180 functioning machines.”
Nigeria has less than 40 trained radiation oncologists and most of the nine comprehensive cancer treatment centres in Nigeria are, according to Olasinde, either “obsolete or non-functional”.
While cancer is more prevalent in wealthier countries – rates actually rise with increasing levels of income – the mortality rate is much higher in poorer countries such as Nigeria. The World Health Organisation estimates that more than 100,000 Nigerians are diagnosed with cancer each year, and 80,000 die from the disease. In the UK, where more people develop cancer, the rate of survival is 50%.
Campaigners and politicians across Nigeria are pushing to promote the kind of cancer care seen in wealthier countries, with an emphasis on prevention, early diagnosis and screening and survivor support.
NGOs such as the Abuja-based Health and Psychological Trust Centre – known as Project Pink Blue – are bringing best practice in cancer care to the city.
Having built up an awareness-raising programme that travels to rural areas to explain the signs of cancer and tell people how to prevent it, the centre has just begun Nigeria’s first breast cancer support group, made up of nine cancer survivors.
“Until we begin to change the way our people think about cancer we cannot change late detection of cancer,” says Runcie Chidebe, executive director of the centre.
Chidebe says that many people are unaware of behavioural and dietary risks that trigger cancer, including high body mass index, low fruit and vegetable intake, lack of physical activity, tobacco use and alcohol intake.
“The only way we can change the narrative of cancer being a death sentence is to get strong voices against cancer,” he says. “Strong voices against cancer cannot even be the doctors, neither can they be me nor the media. Strong voices of cancer are strong champions – the cancer survivors themselves. We have nine survivors right now, and we are mobilising more.”
Besides awareness campaigns, the group supports cancer patients through fundraising. It was through one such fundraising event that the NGO raised around 5.5m naira (£14,000) in cash and 9m naira in drug support to enable Daniel to have her chemotherapy when her savings ran out.
“I used up all the money I saved for my schooling for treatment, and when it finished I stayed away from treatment for more than a year until Mr Runcie came to my rescue,” Daniel says.
Politicians want to capitalise on the growing understanding of how to treat cancer. Muhammadu Usman is a lawmaker in the lower chamber of Nigeria’s legislature. With colleagues, he is sponsoring a bill calling for the establishment of national agency on cancer control. The bill has passed first and second readings and is due for a public hearing soon.
“Until we establish an agency that will handle cancer there is no way Nigeria can make any process,” he says. “When you have an agency, you will able to appropriate money, you will be able to recruit staff, the agency will be given certain responsibilities on mobilisation, treatment and prevention or seek international support.”
Usman notes that none of the country’s hospitals are properly equipped to provide the necessary medication to cancer patients. Citing recommendations from the International Atomic Energy Agency, he says South Africa has 18 functional machines for cancer treatment, Japan has 611 and China has 453.
Nigeria is supposed to have around 800 machines to treat cancer, such as an external beam radiotherapy machine, but none are working properly.
For Comfort Daniel, the new ways of supporting cancer patients are as important as working machinery. “After I was diagnosed with cancer, for three days I was unable to sleep. This is why the Abuja breast cancer support group is important. Nobody can understand the pains of the patient like a survivor,” she says. “There was a day I visited the hospital and came across an elderly woman who had breast cancer and was looking so sad. She refused to eat. But after speaking to her, she cheered up and took her food. Nobody can understand the pains we pass through, not even doctors.”
Join our community of development professionals and humanitarians. Follow @GuardianGDP on Twitter.
Social care in England is at risk of imminent collapse in the worst affected areas unless urgent steps are taken to address the crisis engulfing the sector, Age UK has warned.
The charity’s latest report on the healthcare of older people calls for a cash injection into the adult social care system in the spring budget and the development of a long-term solution to a problem that will otherwise become more acute.
Analysis previously published by Age UK suggests almost 1.2 million people aged 65 and over do not receive the care and support they need with essential daily activities such as eating, dressing and bathing.
That figure has shot up by 17.9% in just a year and almost by 50% since 2010, with nearly one in eight now living with some level of unmet need, it says.
Age UK’s charity director, Caroline Abrahams, said the report makes for “frightening reading”, adding: “Unless something changes the crisis will certainly deepen this year and next, and we think there is now a real risk of a complete collapse in social care in the worst affected areas. If this happened it would be a disaster that would threaten the health and even the lives of the older people affected. It would also greatly intensify pressure on our hospitals.
“Some older people and their families are already telling us that they simply cannot find any carers where they live, and we are also hearing of vulnerable older people receiving council-funded care whose help has been significantly reduced, leaving them to manage alone for many hours at a time.”
The charity says the government’s three ways of propping up the system – financial transfers from the NHS, a social care precept in local areas, and calling on families and friends to do more – are inadequate and cannot make up for a “chronic” shortfall of public funds. The report, published on Thursday, says the NHS can ill-afford to bail out social care, the amount the precept (an additional council tax charge) can raise does not match the needs in every area, particularly poorer ones, and the number of families and friends becoming carers is not keeping pace with a rising ageing population.
It concludes that the government’s strategy for keeping the social care system from falling apart is not up to scratch. The charity warns that the situation will only deteriorate further as rising demand is accompanied by budget cuts and more care home providers pulling out of the market.
Margaret Willcox, president-elect of the Association of Directors of Adult Social Services, said the report “reflects the concerns of the whole sector united in the belief that adult social care is at risk of failure to chronic underfunding”.
A government spokesman said it was making £7.6bn of new money available for adult social care: “This government has gone further to integrate health and social care than any other before it. We have brought budgets together for the first time through the Better Care Fund and given the NHS an extra £10bn per year by 2020/21 to fund its own plan to build a more responsive, modern health system.”
People have just as much of a duty to look after their elderly parents as they do to care for their own children, a health minister has said.
David Mowat made the comments alongside an admission that the government had no “final answer” on how it was going to cope with the rising costs of social care.
Speaking to the House of Commons’ select committee on communities and local government, the minister said that tackling the care crisis involved “interwoven issues” including the question of how society deals with the care of ageing parents.
“One of the things that has struck me is no one ever questions that we look after our children – that is obvious. No one says that is a caring responsibility, it is what we do,” he said.
“I think some of that logic and some of the way we think about that in terms the volume of numbers that we are seeing coming down the track will have to impinge on the way that we think about caring for our parents. Because it is a responsibility in terms of our life cycle which is similar.”
The comments come as the Local Government Association, which represents more than 370 councils in England and Wales, claimed that the social care system was on the brink of collapse. The group is warning the chancellor, Philip Hammond, before the spring budget that failure to act urgently to plug the funding gap could leave councils open to legal challenges as they fail to fulfil their duties under the Care Act.
“The intentions and the spirit of the Care Act that aims to help people to live well and independently are in grave danger of falling apart and failing unless new funding is announced by government for adult social care,” said Cllr Izzi Seccombe, who chairs the LGA’s community wellbeing board.
She said social care was not just about getting people washed and dressed but aspiring to help people live the fullest of lives and with dignity.
Speaking to MPs on the committee, Mowat admitted that demand was rising and social care would inevitably require the UK to spend a higher proportion of its overall income on supporting elderly and disabled people.
“What we do know when we look at the GDP that we spend on care, we spend more than some countries like Germany that we would consider to be comparative and more than Canada,” he said.
But he admitted the total spend would inevitably rise, partly because of an ageing population and because of rapidly rising life expectancy among people with learning disabilities whose care was very expensive.
Mowat said there were “discussions with the Treasury all of the time” about how to cope with the demand.
“Over a period of time, the amount of money our society will spend on care will increase. You then get into what the options are and that is a wider question. There have been a lot of reviews. We are unusual in Europe in that we don’t have a social insurance system or long-term savings scheme,” he said.
The minister said personally he felt that such schemes could only help in the very long term and suggested there was a more pressing need to tackle the issue, including through societal changes.
Part of the answer was ensuring that people felt the responsibility to care for elderly mothers and fathers, said Mowat. He talked about the high levels of “informal caring” that already take place, saying six million people were taking on some form of care responsibility, including 200,000 children, alongside 1.6 million full-time carers.
“Part of the solution is properly bringing those informal carers into some kind of system,” he said, highlighting plans for a carers’ strategy that could help people get back into the workplace. “If people doing more than 10 hours of care a week, it is hard to get back into work.”
‘It’s like being at home,” was the verdict that one resident at West Hall, a care home in West Byfleet, relayed to inspectors. When you walk through the doors, you can see why. The first thing that strikes a visitor is its immaculate grounds and impressive architecture, which blends a beautifully converted old manor house with three eco-build residential lodges.
But the impressive surroundings fade into the background when you start talking to the people who live and work in West Hall. The warmth and affection that characterise the relationships between staff and residents light up its smart interior, creating a comfortable, homely atmosphere. Arriving on a Thursday lunchtime, I’m introduced to several relatives visiting their parents: Nigel Allen, the home’s manager, stresses they are welcomed with open arms. There’s a huge range of activities to take part in: the day I was there, they included a sing-along, a lunch outing to the local pub and a Scrabble group.
West Hall, run by the not-for-profit Anchor Trust, is not a typical care service. It is one of the few homes to have received an outstanding rating from the regulator. Data provided to the Observer by the Care Quality Commission shows that there are just 91 outstanding care homes in England for the over-65s – less than 1% of those the CQC has inspected under its new regime. Almost one in three have been rated as requiring improvement or as inadequate. The quality of care provided to older people in their own homes is similarly variable.
Another thing that sets West Hall apart is that it doesn’t seem particularly short of resources. Set in a leafy corner of Surrey, where very few older people qualify for state support with the costs of their care, all of its residents are privately funded. Its fees put it at the high end of the market. Walking through its excellent facilities, there’s a sense that money is no object, and there’s one carer for every four residents.
Care homes and homecare agencies that rely at least in part on public funds face a far more straitened set of circumstances. Council funding for adult social care has fallen by 11% on average since 2010, and in some areas by as much as 30%. Cuts to local government funding, together with increasing demand as the population ages, and rising costs as a result of higher regulatory standards and the introduction of the “national living wage”, have created a perfect storm for councils.
The government points to the introduction of the social care precept, a new measure allowing councils to charge an extra 2% on top of their council tax rates to pay for care services from this year. But new analysis by the King’s Fund exclusively for the Observer shows the precept will raise just 3% of what councils are already spending on social care this year. The 10 most affluent areas will raise more than twice as much as the 10 most deprived areas, further widening inequalities in older people’s access to care. Another source of extra funding, the Better Care Fund, will not kick in substantially for another few years.
“Services supporting our loved ones are close to breaking point”, says Izzi Seccombe, chair of the Local Government Association’s community wellbeing board. “The system with which we provide state-funded care to the elderly really is on the brink of financial failure.”
As a result of funding cuts, councils have reduced the rates they pay care-home providers and homecare services for residents who get financial support. Some local authorities are now paying just £330 a week for a care-home place, which works out at less than £2 an hour. It’s becoming increasingly common for providers to cross-subsidise the fees of those who are council-funded using the fees of private funders: industry research suggests privately funded residents are paying up to 40% more for a like-for-like service.
Councils have serious concerns about the sustainability of the care market. According to the Local Government Association, 48 councils have seen at least one home care provider cease trading in the past six months, and a further 77 councils have lost at least one residential or nursing care provider.
The number of people getting state support to help with the cost of their care has also fallen by more than 25% in the past five years. Age UK estimates that there are now more than a million older people who struggle without the help they need to carry out everyday tasks, such as getting out of bed, going to the toilet and getting dressed.
“Growing numbers of older people are going without enough care or, in some deeply worrying cases, no care at all,” says Caroline Abrahams, charity director of Age UK. “Ultimately this means many older people are living sadder and lonelier later lives, a tragedy for them and for our society.” Gary FitzGerald, chief executive of the charity Action on Elder Abuse, says a lack of support is having a knock-on impact on safeguarding referrals for neglect, which have increased by 24% in the past four years. “Someone is having to support them. Often it’s family and friends trying to do their best without the skills, knowledge and equipment to care for them securely and safely.”
He remembers a case that emerged a couple of years ago of an elderly woman who tied her husband, a dementia sufferer, to a chair in order to go out shopping. “All the weight of criticism came down on her. But she couldn’t get any help with her husband’s care, so she couldn’t get out to shop. She was damned if she did, damned if she didn’t. That’s the sort of choice we’re forcing people to make.”
Beyond the tragic human cost, the care funding crisis is having a severe impact on the NHS. A lack of state-funded care means thousands of older people are left languishing on hospital wards when they are well enough to be discharged, costing the NHS £800m a year. It also drives more older people to hospital: it is vastly more expensive to treat a broken hip than to prevent it by helping with washing and dressing.
The funding crisis has been a long time in the making. “The need for action was recognised as long ago as 1997, when Tony Blair established a royal commission on the funding of long-term care,” says Richard Humphries, assistant director of policy at the King’s Fund. “There have been three significant reviews and commissions since then. The problem is not a lack of evidence or solutions.” Rather, the issue seems to be the lack of political willpower. “When the NHS is in trouble, we see the visual evidence,” Humphries adds. “Images of overflowing hospitals and queuing ambulances. The consequences of stretched care services are far less visible. Care does not resonate as a significant issue in MPs’ postbags and surgeries in the same way.”
Many believe the solutions required are so long-term that they will only be delivered through a degree of cross-party consensus. Cross-party talks were started a few years ago, but broke down acrimoniously just before the general election in 2010.
Andrea Sutcliffe, the chief inspector of adult social care, has warned that the funding predicament risks jeopardising quality of care. “The reduction in resources and the level of unmet need means adult social care is reaching a tipping point,” she told the Observer. “There is a fragility and a lack of resilience in the sector which I am very concerned about … It’s leading us into situations where we don’t have enough trained staff to deliver good care.”
Many councils struggle to find good-quality care for their residents. “I’m worried about the quality of care homes available locally,” says Rebecca Lury, a Southwark councillor who chairs the authority’s health scrutiny committee. “Earlier this year the council was in a position where one care home announced its closure following an inadequate rating from the regulator. It had to move residents to another care home; it had also put in special measures.”
Some councils are still commissioning 15-minute care visits, despite strong government guidance that such cursory visits are seen as wholly inadequate.
John Kennedy, former director of care services at the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, believes funding isn’t the only problem. He published a personal inquiry into the quality of care homes in 2014, and since then has spent time visiting outstanding care homes to find out what makes them different.
Too many carers face poor pay and working conditions. But John Kennedy also believes the care system fails to support care-home managers adequately – a job often invisible to society at large. “This is a job with an immense level of responsibility,” he says. “In a home with over 50 residents, you might have a staff team of the same number, with turnover around the £2m mark. All care homes are 24/7 operations. The show must relentlessly go on.”
Yet average pay for a care-home manager is just £27,700 a year. “I doubt you could find any other job in any other sector that requires this level of responsibility for that level of pay.”
He believes government has placed too much emphasis on red tape and regulation as a way to improve care services. “We’ve created a system that makes it too difficult for any but the most skilled managers to deliver consistently good care,” he says. “Instead of valuing relationships, people and life, we concentrate on value, systems and processes. The system puts avoiding blame above ensuring people are having a good life. This attitude permeates and damages the culture of care.”
Kennedy is worried that, given the relentless nature of their role, care-home managers are at risk of burning out: on average, one in four care managers leave every year. He argues that this makes quality in care homes fundamentally fragile, citing the example of one care home he visited that was rated outstanding by the regulator, but whose standards plummeted to inadequate after it lost its manager.
If it’s great management that makes a great care home, it’s poor management that paves the way for the kind of abuse that has been periodically uncovered by the media, according to FitzGerald. “Where you see abuse situations in a care home, you’ll see bad leadership with 40 or 50 ordinary people working in an environment that’s abusive and neglectful, and not seeing anything wrong with it,” he says.
The relentless nature of the job means care home managers burn out. Photograph: F1 Online / Rex Features
FitzGerald doesn’t believe incidents of abuse are isolated or rare incidents that can be dismissed. He points to the fact that there has been no reduction in the use of antipsychotic drugs in care homes, despite a 2009 government review that concluded they were overused to the detriment of patients. His charity has raised concerns with the CQC that relatives who have complained about the quality of care have been banned from homes, or told they will have to move out their elderly relatives within 28 days.
He doesn’t mince his words. “We’ve created an institutionally abusive environment in social care. It’s ageism in action.”
Sara McKee, the founder of Evermore, agrees we have a problem with ageism. “Why is it considered acceptable to institutionalise older people when other forms of institutionalisation have been eradicated?” she asks. “Our fundamental model of care has not changed for over 40 years. Modern nursing homes look like they did decades ago, just with newer carpets.” McKee is setting up a new model of supported housing designed to be somewhere people can live their life out, regardless of how high their level of need escalates. “Many health and care providers see ageing as a condition that needs to be managed. We want to provide positive choices where growing older means doing what you love and feeling good, rather than managing declining health.”
The Evermore concept is based on the Green House ageing project in the US, developed by geriatrician Bill Thomas, with whom she now works. She describes the Green House as an “anti-institutional” environment. “He has stripped away all the hospital-like paraphernalia you would find in many traditional care homes, such as nursing stations, uniforms and rigid schedules. In its place is a building designed like a family home, with self-contained residences for six to 12 people.”
Unlike in traditional supported housing, the emphasis is on communal living, with meals prepared in an open kitchen and shared at a communal dining table. McKee says the staff are absolutely key to making it all work: she describes them as multiskilled and self-managed, with much more freedom to run the household according to the wishes of the residents, rather than top-down diktat from head office.
It has taken McKee a while to find an investor for her project, but she’s now working with a developer to build the UK’s first Evermore community in Wigan. But won’t it only be wealthier baby-boomers who can afford this type of living? McKee doesn’t think so. “Most local authorities want to stop paying for grim and expensive nursing home beds,” she says. She believes joining up NHS and council budgets could enable money to be spent on more innovative ways of delivering care like Evermore, not necessarily at higher cost.
Alex Fox is another person rethinking traditional models of care. He runs Shared Lives Plus, a network of local schemes in which paid carers share their home and family life with an adult who needs care or support. The goal is to share an ordinary family life, in which everyone contributes and benefits. This is a much more explicitly two-way relationship than in traditional professional care. It’s a model that was developed primarily for adults with disabilities, but there are now almost 2,000 older people with care needs using Shared Lives in England.
“The Shared Lives carer makes a positive choice to share their home and family life with the older person, so it’s a real relationship which can last a lifetime, not just a service,” says Fox. “People who use Shared Lives tell us they feel ‘one of the family’, and their relatives often say they feel like there are two families working together now, whereas before they often felt on their own and struggling.”
It might not be for everyone. But Fox believes that the rest of the care system can learn from it. “Shared Lives schemes spend time recruiting the right people, then giving them the space and freedom to be more human and flexible in their work. This isn’t just more cost-effective, it creates better care,” he says, pointing to the fact that, out of the 25 Shared Lives schemes rated by the CQC, 24 are good or outstanding.
Is there any work that is more fundamentally human than caring for others? Little wonder then that, whether it’s West Hall, the Green House or Shared Lives, the golden thread that runs through successful care organisations is the quality of their staff.
Perhaps this offers society a golden opportunity. From assembly-line manufacturing to book-keeping to driving a minicab, jobs that once required human endeavour are being replaced by technology. Jobs requiring uniquely human skills like empathy and care may take up a growing share of the labour market in the future. Older care falls into this category, especially given the needs of an ageing population.
Yet care is not exactly a career destination of choice for many young people. Charlotte Whittaker, 22, is halfway through a five-month work placement at care homes in Surrey. It’s a career she’d recommend, but she doesn’t think young people tend to see it as fulfilling or enriching. “Partly it’s a misconception about what care involves. There’s not much understanding of the relational aspects, and the potential to make a difference to a lot of lives over a career.” But she says it is also partly the misperception of care as a low-skill job. “I’ve been incredibly impressed by the skills and diplomacy of the carers I’ve been working with.”
Perhaps by investing more time, money and love in our care system, we can simultaneously improve the lot of both the older and younger generations. That’s an attractive proposition at a time when so much political debate seems to set the young against the old. But it’s not a job that can solely be left to the politicians. Nothing will change unless we face up to the reality that the way we as a society care for older people is just a mirror that reflects back our cultural attitudes towards ageing.
THE MANAGER
Karen Cooper at Greensleeves Care Home in Tunbridge Wells in Kent. Photograph: Richard Saker for the Observer
Karen Cooper runs Mount Ephraim House, a Greensleeves care home in Tunbridge Wells. “My job is demanding, incredibly demanding, but I adore what I do,” she says. “You get so much back from it. You wouldn’t do this job for the money, but because you care about making a difference at the end of the day.”
It takes a high level of skill to care properly for someone with dementia, she says. “They might constantly ask you the same question day in day out, looking for a family member long passed on. You have to be careful how you respond, otherwise a person can go through the grieving process eight times a day.”
It’s not a nine-to-five job. “You can’t really switch off. You’re on call 24 hours a day unless you’re on holiday.” She used to work for a standalone home, which she found more difficult than working for a care home group. “You’re on your own – you don’t have any backup.”
While she loves her work, Cooper feels it’s sad the care sector has to fight its own corner because of the negative publicity generated by stories of abuse. “Sadly, the general public think all care homes are the same, when there are an incredible number of excellent care homes.”
THE CARE WORKER
Charlotte Whittaker, who is doing a five-month placement as a carer. Photograph: Jill Mead for the Guardian
Charlotte Whittaker, 22, is halfway through a five-month work placement as part of an activities team in two care homes in Surrey. She’s doing the work as part of Year Here, a postgraduate qualification in social innovation.
Having seen both her grandmothers need care, she has a close personal interest in the subject. “Elder care is a big societal issue that isn’t necessarily very glamorous but needs a lot of thought and innovation”, she says. “The best thing about my work is the residents: getting to know them as individuals, finding out about their lives and what they like doing now. There are a lot of laughter moments, singing or doing arts and crafts.” But there are harder moments too. “Sometimes you have residents who are very upset, and it’s difficult to comfort them, because the person they’re missing isn’t around any more, or they want to go home but no longer have a house.”
She has been overwhelmed by the emotional investment made by her colleagues in the people they care for: “They do it because they love doing it.”
THE DAUGHTER
Michele Simmons’ mother suffered neglect in her care home.
Michele Simmons thought the small privately owned care home in London she carefully chose for her 77-year-old mother, Gilda, (pictured below) who has dementia, was a warm and welcoming place. However, neglect soon became evident in a number of ways. “My mother was someone who took great pride in her appearance and I took time labelling all her clothes,” says Michele. “But she was increasingly put in other people’s clothes, things that didn’t fit.”
She recalls finding her mother in plastic shoes two sizes too small, her toes bent over. “Mum couldn’t speak, but her face conveyed the pain,” says Michele.
One freezing winter morning, Gilda was sent to hospital in an ambulance. “She was in a thin nightie with no slippers, no blanket, no notes and no one went with her,” says Michele. “The manager said it was because there was a changeover of staff and no one was available. I eventually found her hours later, terrified, on a trolley in a hospital corridor.”
Michele, who paid £3,500 a month for her mother’s care, talked to the manager many times but her complaints were brushed aside. “I became worried about making too much fuss in case they [the care home] took it out on mum. All I wanted was the best for my mum and for her to be treated with dignity and kindness – it was just a shame the home didn’t feel the same.”
THE WHISTLEBLOWER
“Witnessing the abuse and not being able to do anything about it was the worst thing I had to endure,” says Alex Matthews, a former care home worker who was shocked by what he saw during a year at an “expensive and luxury” home. “Rough handling by carers was evident on a daily basis,” he says. “Feeding was done in a hurry and people were often left dribbling porridge and other food over their clothes. Personal hygiene was terrible. ”
But most of those he worked with were good people, he adds. “The neglect was to do with the heavy workloads and having too many people to deal with in a short space of time.” As bad as the physical neglect, he says, was the lack of care over patients’ emotional wellbeing. “We were always asked to move from one to the next as quickly as possible. This leaves you with a lot of guilt.”
Alex Matthews (his pen name) has written a book about his care home experience; She’ll be Alright, Pavilion Publishing, £19.95.
Theresa May is under intense pressure from senior doctors and a powerful cross-party alliance of politicians to avert a collapse in care for the elderly, as shocking new figures show the system close to meltdown.
The medical profession, together with Tory, Labour and Liberal Democrat leaders in local government, have demanded a funding U-turn, warning that the safety of millions of elderly people is at risk because of an acute financial crisis completely overlooked in chancellor Philip Hammond’s autumn statement.
New figures obtained by the Observer show that 77 of the 152 local authorities responsible for providing care for the elderly have seen at least one residential and nursing care provider close in the last six months, because cuts to council budgets meant there were insufficient funds to run adequate services.
In 48 councils, at least one company that provides care for the elderly in their own homes has ceased trading over the same period, placing councils under sudden and huge pressure to find alternative provision.
In addition, 59 councils have had to find new care arrangements after contracts were handed back by a provider who decided that they were unable to make ends meet on the money that councils were able to pay them.
The medical profession, council leaders and even the former Tory health secretary, Andrew Lansley, are appalled that the social care crisis – exacerbated by growing numbers of elderly people and the rising costs of paying staff – was not addressed in the autumn statement.
In a letter to the Observer, the leaders of the four main political groups in local government expressed their disquiet at the chancellor’s dismissing talk of a crisis despite calls from politicians, NHS leaders, doctors and others.
Former Tory health secretary Andrew Lansley is among the critics. Photograph: David Jones/PA
“The fact the government appears to have chosen not to act will lower the quality of life for our elderly and vulnerable residents,” they said.
The cross-party group adds that, without an urgent injection of extra money to fund a £2.6bn funding gap, “the quality and safety of care of our elderly is at risk and the vulnerable will increasingly struggle to receive the help they need to meet basic needs such as washing, dressing or getting out of bed”.
They added that May cannot claim to be governing for everyone if she fails to act to help the elderly and most vulnerable: “The social care crisis is real and it is happening right now. The government cannot ignore it any longer if we are to truly have a society that works for everyone.”
Providers of social care say they have been squeezed by a combination of cuts to local authority funds provided by central government and their own rising costs, particularly as a result of the introduction of the national living wage.
Separately, the president of the Royal College of Surgeons, Clare Marx, told the Observer that the failure to provide adequate care in the home means elderly people are ending up stuck in hospitals, putting huge strain on their finances at a time when government is also demanding large efficiency savings. The logjam means operations for other patients have to be cancelled, causing further added bills to the NHS.
John McDonnell says autumn statement ‘offers no hope’
Marx said surgeons and other medical staff increasingly feel they are failing the elderly: “Cuts to local authorities’ social care budgets result in older people staying in hospital much longer than is necessary. Elderly patients, many of whom are living at home alone with little support, are regularly being admitted to A&E after falls or for acute infections. They then get stuck in hospitals because there is nowhere for them to go to continue their recovery.
“It is incredibly sad to see this happen, and we feel that we are failing our older people towards the end of their lives – when they deserve more dignity and greater support to stay in their own homes.
“Regrettably this has a knock-on effect for planned operations. I am hearing more and more regularly from colleagues who have had to cancel planned procedures because there aren’t enough beds free on wards to admit patients for their surgery. As a result the NHS is becoming increasingly inefficient. It is a vicious circle that won’t end until we properly resource social and community care.”
In the autumn statement debate, Hammond responded to Labour MPs who demanded action on social care by saying: “I know that it is tempting for opposition members to paint everything as a crisis or to talk of looming chaos, but that is not the case.”
He added: “We have created a better care fund that will be delivering £1.5bn a year into social care by the end of this parliament. We have allowed local authorities to raise a social care precept, which will be delivering another £2bn a year by the end of this parliament. That is £3.5bn a year of additional funding into the social care system.”
Council leaders say that Hammond’s claims are completely untrue and that the extra money councils can raise will not come close even to what is needed to meet the cost of introducing the national living wage (estimated to be at least £600m this year).
They also argue that wealthier areas, where more people can afford private care, will be better-placed because they collect more of their budgets through council tax and are less reliant on government funding. More deprived areas will be hit doubly hard because they will have to cope with the deep government funding cuts while being unable to raise as much to meet rising costs.
As a Certified Aromatherapist I am passionate about helping people use essential oils safely. Most essential oils can be applied to the skin safely as long as they are properly diluted with a carrier oil. Of course, some essential oils carry their own guidelines in order to ensure safe topical application, please be sure to research every essential oil prior to use to ensure you are blending within the guidelines of that particular essential oil.
In my previous blog post I covered some basics when it comes to proper essential oil dilution. In this post, I want to go a little more in depth so you can rest assured you are using essential oils safely.
An essential oil is a volatile plant compound. Being volatile means that essential oils evaporate quickly. Their note (Top, middle or base) determines just how fast they evaporate. Generally speaking we can say that:
Citrus peels are top notes and will evaporate the fastest. Some examples: Lemon (Citrus limon) & Grapefruit (Citrus paradisi)
Flowers, Leaves and Stems are middle notes and will evaporate the second fastest. Some examples: Cypress (Cupressus sempervirens) & Geranium (Pelargonium roseum X asperum)
*An exception would be Ylang Ylang (Cananga odorata) which is distilled from flowers but is considered more of a base note than a middle note*
Roots are base notes and will evaporate the third fastest. Some examples: Spikenard (Nardostachys jatamansi or Nardostachys grandiflora) & Vetiver (Vetiveria zizanoides)
You can see from the examples above how notes play a part in aromatherapy. By looking at the note of an essential oil you can determine how quickly it will evaporate in a blend. Diluting essential oils in a carrier is a must in order to allow the essential oil to “hang out” longer than it would if you were to apply the essential oil neat. By diluting the essential oil properly in a carrier, you end up using less essential oil and the outcome will be just as effective. Most essential oils can be applied to the skin safely as long as they are properly diluted.
*Neat use of an essential oil refers to using the essential oil straight from the bottle and applying it to the skin.
Essential oils are extremely concentrated. If you are making a blend for daily use and are a typical healthy adult, a 2% dilution (10-12 drops of essential oil per ounce of carrier) or less would be recommended. If you are blending for a child, the elderly or someone that is pregnant, there are extra considerations that need to be taken into effect.
Pregnancy
During pregnancy, the first trimester is considered the most crucial in terms of fetal development.
Essential oil use during the first trimester should only be used on occasion such as inhaling for morning sickness.
During the second and third trimesters, essential oil use should be limited to an as needed basis at a 1% dilution (5-6 drops of essential oils per ounce of carrier).
Neat use, oral, rectal and vaginal use is not appropriate during pregnancy.
All solvent extracted (absolutes) essential oils, poor quality oils and perfumes should be avoided while pregnant.
There are roughly 50 or so essential oils that should be avoided all together during pregnancy, please be sure to consult a Certified Aromatherapist, Midwife or other qualified practitioner prior to using essential oils while pregnant. While there isn’t an authoritative list per se of which essential oils are safe or unsafe its best to choose essential oils with a history of low toxicity.
Elderly
Caution should be noted when making a blend for the elderly population, their skin tends to be thinner than that of a typical healthy adult.
Elderly tend to have a lower irritation threshold when it comes to essential oil use than that of a typical healthy adult.
Recommended dilution for the elderly population is 1% or less (a 1% dilution is 5-6 drops of essential oil per ounce of carrier).
Essential oils should always be properly diluted when working with the elderly population. Neat use is not recommended unless under the supervision of a Certified Aromatherapist or other qualified health practitioner.
Children
Let me start this category by saying, as a Certified Aromatherapist I take an extremely conservative approach when it comes to essential oil use and children. Children are much more delicate than a typical healthy adult. I have found in my practice that herbally infused oils and/or hydrosols can give their little bodies the nudge it needs to get back on track without ever having to use essential oils. Children and essential oils have caused much debate on a number of Facebook groups I am a part of. I have seen a lot of individuals recommend dilutions for children that would be appropriate for a typical adult, however children come with their own set of dilution guidelines.
To put it into a better perspective, I like to use this analogy with my clients; If an adult dose of Tylenol cures your headache, you wouldn’t in turn give that same adult does to your 2 year old when they are complaining of a headache, now would you? There are specially formulated variations of Tylenol for children and babies based on their delicate systems. Essential oil formulations are no different.
General Guidelines for Children
Age < 2 years – Consult a Certified Aromatherapist
Age 2 – 4 years – Only use essential oils on an as needed basis for this age group at a dilution of .05% or less. Keep in mind certain essential oils carry safety considerations for children that should be taken into account
Age 5 – 12 years – Essential oils may be used at a 1% dilution (5-6 drops per ounce of carrier). Keep in mind certain essential oils carry safety considerations for children that should be taken into account
Very low ambient intermittent* inhalation is generally safe for babies ages 3 months and up and children that are too young for topical application. When diffusing around babies and children essential oils should limited to just a few drops per 24 hours. Be sure to choose extremely gentle age appropriate essential oils and keep diffuser use to 30 minutes at a time. Diffuser use with babies and small children should be limited and used on an as needed basis. When in doubt be sure to consult a Certified Aromatherapist.
*Intermittent use refers to 30 minutes on, 30 minutes off
I can not stress enough how important it is to use caution when utilizing essential oils with children. Essential oils are extremely concentrated substances. Often times children are too young to effectively communicate if they are having an adverse reaction to an essential oil blend. Please be sure to consult a Certified Aromatherapist or other knowledgeable practitioner when making a blend for a child and always be sure to research the particular essential oil you are choosing to use to be sure there aren’t any safety precautions that need to be considered.
As you can see there are so many factors that come into play when formulating an essential oil blend. I hope this post sheds some light on additional safety factors that should be taken into consideration when creating the perfect essential oil blend for a friend or loved one.
Looking for more dilution guidelines with a handy chart? Be sure to check out my other blog post here. Questions about Aromatherapy or any of the guidelines above? Feel free to email me at Sara@Pneuma.online or go to my website Pneuma.online
Elderly people are bearing the brunt of cuts to social care, according to a new report that also warns of increasing numbers of care homes going bust.
The study, from the King’s Fund and Nuffield Trust, found that the care and support older people received depended on where they lived and how rich they were rather than their level of need.
Reductions in how much local authorities pay care homes – or below-inflation increases – mean that some are on the brink of collapse, leaving vulnerable people at risk.
The cuts, combined with shortages of nurses and care workers, the introduction of the national living wage for staff and increasing reliance on people who can self-pay means many care homes are under unprecedented pressure, the report said.
It warned of future firms going bust, in a similar way to the collapse of Southern Cross in 2011, and others leaving the market.
It said: “The possibility of large-scale provider failures is no longer a question of if but when, and such a failure would jeopardise continuity of the care on which older people depend.”
Over the past five years, local authority spending on care for older and disabled people has fallen by 11% in real terms and the number of people who received state-funded help had fallen by around a quarter.
This means growing numbers of people are now outside the system, struggling with basic needs such as washing, dressing or getting out of bed.
The report warned: “No one has a full picture of what has happened to older people who are no longer entitled to publicly-funded care: the human and financial costs to them and those who care for them are mounting.”
Unpaid carers, such as family and friends, will be expected to do even more in future, the report added. It said public spending on adult social care was set to fall to less than 1% of GDP by 2020, adding that councils would struggle to meet basic statutory duties.
The fact care is becoming more about what people can afford means those who are “relatively well off and well informed” will do better than the poorest, “who are reliant on an increasingly threadbare local authority safety net”.
The report also pointed to the rapid growth in delayed discharges from hospital – so-called bed-blocking, which is now at its highest ever level – as a symptom of issues with social care.
Richard Humphries, assistant director of policy at the King’s Fund, said: “The failure of successive governments to reform social care has resulted in a failing system that leaves older people, their families and carers to pick up the pieces.
“Putting this right will be a key test of the prime minister’s promise of a more equal country that works for everyone – there is no more burning injustice in Britain today than older people being denied the care they need to live with independence and dignity.”
Ruth Thorlby, deputy director of policy at the Nuffield Trust, said: “No one can predict whether they will have care needs later in life. But if they do find they need help with the basics – eating, washing, going to the toilet – most will discover that unlike a health problem, where care is free, they somehow have to manage themselves.
“Our research found that local authorities have done their best to make savings while protecting funding for the poorest, but care providers are struggling on the low fees councils can afford.
“Shortages of home care staff and affordable care home places mean older people are often stuck in hospital, putting both their lives and vital NHS processes on hold. The number of older people needing care is increasing and yet we are continuing to put less money in.”
Figures show a 26% reduction in the numbers of older people receiving local authority-funded care, from more than 1.1 million in 2009 to 853,615 in 2013-14.
Phil McCarvill, deputy director of policy at the NHS Confederation, said: “Insufficient social care funding is now the most urgent threat to the NHS and the wider health and care system.”
The parliamentary and health service ombudsman, Julie Mellor, added: “Our investigations have uncovered that older patients often fall through the cracks between health and social care when discharged from hospital, causing them and their families untold distress and suffering.
“The issues of funding and lack of integration between health and social care need to be addressed so that older people get the support they so desperately need.”
A Department of Health spokesman said: “We understand the social care system is under pressure, and this government is committed to ensuring those in old age throughout the country can get affordable and dignified care.
“That’s why we have introduced landmark reforms to ensure no-one should have to sell their home to pay for care in their lifetime, and why we’re significantly increasing the amount of money local authorities have access to for social care, by up to £3.5bn by 2020.
“Our Care Act gave new rights to carers and we will be publishing a new carers strategy shortly.”
Theresa May’s policy chief has suggested that people with valuable homes who face high social care costs in old age should downsize or re-mortgage to cover their bills, the Observer can reveal.
Director of policy John Godfrey has suggested that over the next 10 years the solution to the social care crisis lies in people selling up or releasing some of the equity in their property.
“On a 10-year view … equity release is going to be hugely important, because if you look at the amount of housing equity across the UK that is owned by people of post-retirement age, that is really where an awful lot of the money sits at the moment,” Godfrey told an independent commission last year. “Can people either downshift or liberate some of that money through equity release to fund their living costs?”
One in 10 people end up paying more than £100,000 in care costs in old age, research has shown. Equity release involves borrowing against the value of a home or selling all or part of it for a lump sum or a monthly income. Godfrey, who was a special adviser to Douglas Hurd in Margaret Thatcher’s administration, added that he believed the government should encourage people to sell their homes to release cash through the building of suitable retirement homes.
“As far as downshifting is concerned, you move into another area of policy altogether, which is the need to build more housing to give people a choice of the right sort of home.”
Godfrey had been working for insurer Legal & General as corporate affairs director for eight years before his appointment in mid-July. His comments will be controversial, given that they involve the politically toxic suggestion that people should spend their children’s inheritance – in the form of the family home – to cover the costs of social care. In 2013, then health secretary Jeremy Hunt said it was a scandal that every year “30,000 to 40,000 people are having to sell their houses to pay for care costs”.
Last July the government announced it would delay the so-called Dilnot reforms, which included the introduction of a cap intended to limit the liability of those self-funding their social care at £72,000. It was hoped that insurance products would emerge to allow people to cover those costs.
The proposed reforms, at a cost of £6m over five years, also provided for a more generous means test that would have allowed more people to qualify for local authority financial support.
When Alan’s wife, Toby, was diagnosed with Parkinson’s four years ago, the retired geophysicist turned to a not-for-profit in Palo Alto, California – called Avenidas Village – for guidance. Through Avenidas, Alan learned about several online platforms that connect individuals who need home care with workers who provide it.
Now, once a week, Alan opens his Windows PC and logs onto the website of a company called Honor, which lets him summon a “CarePro” the way you would call an Uber. These “nice young women,” usually nursing students, look after Toby while Alan goes to attend a lecture or to rehearse with one of several chamber music groups, for which he plays violin.
For Eleanor, in the Bronx, it was her daughter Carol who made arrangements. “I don’t like computers … I don’t do Facebook,” Eleanor told me, smiling, when I asked how she kept up with her four grandchildren. But confined to a wheelchair after a stroke, Eleanor knew that if she was going to stay in the apartment where she had lived for 51 years with her late husband, she would need constant assistance. Now, two caregivers from Hometeam, a startup providing in-home care to seniors,take turns staying over. They communicate with each other, and with Carol, through an app loaded on a tablet that stands in the center of her coffee table, in a room lined with family portraits and travel souvenirs.
The market
Silicon Valley skews young and its companies are notoriously ageist. When Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg turned 30 in 2014, the internet gleefully reminded him that he once said that he would hesitate to hire anyone that old. Another popular witticism is that San Francisco’s tech culture is focused on solving one problem: “What is my mother no longer doing for me?” Hence the seemingly endless investment in startups that offer food, laundry and cleaning services.
Conventional wisdom says that you cannot sell tech to the elderly. Yet over the past several years, the sheer size of the market has begun to attract investors. For them, the time has come to ask not what another mommy app can do for you, but what an app could do for your mommy. And big tech investors, like Facebook board member Marc Andreessen, are sensing a major opportunity.
As more ‘digital natives’ become responsible for their parents, they will look for solutions that offer convenience
There are currently around 50 million Americans over the age of 65 , and 10,000 more turn 65 every day. A trillion dollars are spent on healthcare for American seniors every year. And more and more “digital natives” are entering the “sandwich generation”, the age when they are responsible for caring for both their children and their parents, while also meeting the demands of careers. It stands to reason that they will look for solutions that offer convenience, having spent their adult lives with Uber and TaskRabbit and Handy.
Since 2013, several startups have launched with the mission of bringing the on-demand model to elder care. HomeHero, based in Los Angeles, recently announced a program which facilitates transferring patients from the hospital to home with the help of a HomeHero caregiver. Hometeam, headquartered in New York, currently has several hundred caregivers providing services in four east coast states. Honor, in San Francisco, raised $ 20m – led by Andreessen Horowitz – in its first round of funding, and has established partnerships with the American Cancer Association and the American Parkinson’s Association.
Why the rush of investment?
The founders behind these companies are not the first to try to bring tech industry tools to the disorganized field of home care. Care.com was founded in 2006 on the model of an eBay or a Craigslist: it is a website that connects people looking to provide services, from babysitting to standardized test tutoring to elder care, with those who need it. Care.com left it up to users to negotiate their own financial arrangements. (Alan, an Honor user, reported having a terrible experience: “It was only $ 18 an hour, but $ 18 an hour of agony,” he said of a string of workers who proved unreliable.) Carelinx a “professional caregiver marketplace” focused on elders launched at the end of 2011. It was endorsed by theAmerican Association of Retired People. However, it also remained at the level of a platform or marketplace.
Venture capitalist and Andreessen Horowitz co-founder Marc Andreessen, who led investment in home care startup Honor. Photograph: Michael Kovac/Getty Images for Vanity Fair
The new companies are different in that they provide the service themselves. Honor and Hometeam have both developed software designed to match user and care provider and to facilitate communications. Most often, that is with the children of the clients actually receiving the care. The apps also provide protocols for treating patients with particular conditions. Hence, the partnerships that Honor has created with the American Cancer Association and American Parkinson’s Association. Finally, these companies are creating new models to provide training and career development to care providers – a population that is growing along with the population of seniors.
Honor founder Seth Sternberg explains: “When we started looking at the nonmedical home care space, we realized that the problem was that home care professionals are treated really poorly. 56% of them are on some kind of government assistance. If you can’t take care of yourself how should we expect you to take care of someone else?” The average hourly wage of a home healthcare provider in California is $ 9.50. A San Francisco dog-walker, by contrast, earns $ 20.
Honor announced that they were making all of their CarePros employees, rather than independent contractors, in January 2016. Salaries start at $ 17.50 per hour, with healthcare benefits, equity, and opportunities for advancement. They have a huge and growing population of workers to draw on: there are currently between 2 and 3 million non-medical care professionals in the US. HomeHero followed by announcing that they were giving all of their workers W-2 status, with healthcare and benefits, on 1 March. Josh Bruno, the 29-year-old who startedHometeam,told me that they have used employees – not contractors – since the beginning, in July 2015. They currently have over a thousand actively working in four states on the East Coast.
Personal drive
The founders of these companies tell touching personal stories about revelations they had while struggling to care for their own families. For Sternberg, the lightbulb moment came when he was around 35: visiting his mother in Connecticut, he discovered that her driving had slowed to a crawl. For Bruno, it was the experience of watching his family trying to coordinate care for his nonagenarian grandfather. Bruno left his job and started volunteering at home healthcare agencies, convinced that he could learn how to create a company that would do it better.
Related: Big tech asked to pay their ‘fair share’ in taxes to help San Francisco’s homeless
It makes sense that young entrepreneurs would want to disrupt the home healthcare industry, which is valued at $ 80-100bn per year in the US and employs tens of thousands of contract workers across different local agencies. But there are other, more systemic reasons why these startups are well positioned to raise funds and to continue to expand.
New provisions of the Affordable Care Act, which became effective only in April, mean that hospitals will have incentives to coordinate post-release care for their patients. Whereas previously hospitals were reimbursed for such procedures on a case-by-case or a fee-for-service basis – reimbursed by Medicare for each treatment that a patient received – under the new arrangement, a hospital will only be allotted a certain amount of money to pay for treatment of a health issue such as a joint replacement or heart surgery.
This means that hospitals will be penalized if their patients are readmitted, meaning hospitals and insurance companies now have a real incentive to improve care after procedures.
The kinds of services that Honor and Hometeam provide have always been regarded as “non-medical”: the workers who deliver it do not need to have medical training, and are actually prohibited from administering any actual medical care. In the case of Eleanor, whom I visited in the Bronx, her daughter Carol comes once a week to lay out her pills. Her caregivers can only ask “Did you remember to take your pills?” but cannot legally instruct her to take them.
Until now, this kind of care has been performed by very low waged contract workers hired through agencies, and has not been seen as part of medicine or as eligible to be covered by medical insurance.
Ronald Greeno is an in-patient doctor who has worked in Los Angeles for 30 years. He sees this changing, and thinks this is part of what the investors backing the new startups are betting on. “There’s an emerging realization that homecare is healthcare at its most basic. The most basic elements are getting individuals to care for themselves. Are you eating right, exercising, seeing a doctor when we need to, getting the right preventative care done, and so on? That is the essential element of healthcare, and by the way the most cost effective.”
For now, individuals like Alan and Toby, or like Eleanor and her daughter Carol, seem happy to bear the expense – and even to adopt the rhetoric of friendliness that characterizes the relations of employers and employees in so many “disruptive”industries – from ride sharing to co-living spaces.
On the day when I visited Eleanor, she was giving her Ghanaian home health aid, Serwa, instructions on how to prepare sweet potatoes with marshmallow for the Jewish Passover holiday the following week. As Serwa moved around the kitchen, Eleanor beamed: “It will be her first Seder.”