The British nurse who twice came close to death after contracting Ebola while working as a volunteer in Sierra Leone in 2014 should not face charges of dishonesty, a misconduct hearing has heard.
Pauline Cafferkey, 40, could be struck off by the Nursing and Midwifery Council if the remaining charges against her are proved. Those charges are that she allowed an incorrect temperature to be recorded on her return to the UK, and that she failed to report her elevated temperature to screening staff or tell them she had recently taken paracetamol.
On Tuesday morning the panel at an NMC misconduct hearing in Edinburgh was urged by the case presenter for the council to strike out a charge that she had acted dishonestly.
Anu Thompson, for the NMC, told the panel that expert evidence suggested Cafferkey’s “ability to make decisions and reason properly were affected at the relevant time”. She referred to one medical expert, Dr Thomson, who submitted that: “I have no doubt that a combination of early Ebola virus infection and fatigue resulting from a busy night shift followed by a lengthy journey [from Sierra Leone] would have impaired Pauline’s judgement at the time of entering the screening process at Heathrow airport.”
The hearing was told that on 28 December 2014 Public Health England’s Ebola screening facility at Heathrow airport had not been prepared for such a large influx of passengers, and that the screening area was “busy, disorganised and even chaotic”.
An agreed statement of fact described how each person was given a port of entry Ebola health assessment form, on which their temperature and other relevant information was to be recorded by medical staff. As the delays continued and frustrations grew, one member of Cafferkey’s group suggested they take their own temperatures.
The hearing was told that a member of that group, Doctor 1, took Cafferkey’s temperature and found it to be 38.2C, then 38.3C when she took it again a few minutes later.
Doctor 1 stated that she read out both numbers in the presence of Cafferkey and Registrant A, another group member, who said that she would record the nurse’s temperature as 37.2C then they would “get out of here and sort it out”.
Cafferkey, who sat quietly with her representative throughout the hearing, has stated that she remembers somebody using the words “let’s get out of here” but cannot remember who said them or who entered the temperature of 37.2C on her screening form.
Any temperature above 37.5C was considered to be elevated and should have been reported to a consultant for further assessment.
Cafferkey left the screening area, the hearing was told, but later returned after Doctor 1 raised further concerns about her elevated temperature. Her temperature was taken three more times, by Doctor 2, but only one reading was above 37.5C, and that by 0.1C. Cafferkey did not volunteer to Doctor 2 the information that she had recently taken paracetamol, nor was she asked directly about it, and she was cleared to travel home to Glasgow.
The following day she was diagnosed with Ebola, suffering one of the highest viral loads ever recorded.
Earlier on Tuesday, Cafferkey’s representative, Joyce Cullen, applied for the hearing to be held in private, arguing that the “intrusive nature of press and media has already had a significant psychological impact on Miss Cafferkey”.
Cullen added that an error by the NMC in publishing draft charges on their website last month had had an additional adverse effect, after which Cafferkey had required medical treatment and been forced to move out of her home for a period. Cullen argued that Cafferkey had a right to privacy regarding medical records that would be referred to during the hearing.
The assembled media objected to the application for the hearing to be heard in private. A decision was due later on Tuesday after hearing submissions from the media’s legal representatives.
Pauline Cafferkey hearing urged to drop Ebola dishonesty charge
Hiç yorum yok:
Yorum Gönder