Scolding etiketine sahip kayıtlar gösteriliyor. Tüm kayıtları göster
Scolding etiketine sahip kayıtlar gösteriliyor. Tüm kayıtları göster

16 Eylül 2016 Cuma

Dr Oz"s missed opportunity: scolding Trump for all his bad habits | Celine Gounder

On the The Dr Oz Show Thursday, Donald Trump spent only a fraction of the hour discussing his health, on his own terms. There’s still a lot that he – and, for that matter, Hillary Clinton – still haven’t told us, but a superficial, televised chat did little to change that.


Dr Mehmet Oz started off his interview by asking Trump how he stayed healthy. Oz didn’t delve much into the candidate’s diet, though Trump has bragged that he loves fast food. With a body mass index of 29.5, Trump is overweight – practically obese.


As for exercise, Trump says he golfs, but hasn’t much lately, and poked fun at President Barack Obama’s time on the green. “He could play on the PGA tour,” Trump said.


During a commercial break, Dr Oz explained that lack of sleep has been linked to weight gain, heart disease and some cancers. He went on to say that sleep helps regulate your immune system and strengthens your memories. But when Trump told Oz he doesn’t need much sleep, Oz didn’t delve into it.


An occupational hazard of running for president is all the handshaking, which exposes candidates to innumerable viruses and bacteria at a time when they’re exhausted. Trump, a self-professed germaphobe, no doubt carries his own stash of alcohol-based hand sanitizer on the road, as Obama does on the advice of his predecessor, but Oz didn’t inquire about that either.


Dr Oz then moved on to the “Review of Systems,” a long checklist of symptoms that’s usually part of the form you fill out in your doctor’s waiting room. It’s a tool doctors use to jog patients’ memories and elicit additional symptoms of concern. It was cursory, at best.


Trump’s blood pressure and labs were all in the normal range, though his blood glucose, if fasting, was concerning for prediabetes. This would have been a great opportunity for Oz to educate his audience about the links between obesity, diabetes, heart attack, stroke, kidney and liver disease and various other medical conditions. Absent from Dr Harold Bornstein’s report on Trump’s health was a complete blood count and kidney function tests, labs most doctors would order before checking liver and thyroid function tests or a testosterone level. Absent signs or symptoms of disease, it’s unclear that Trump needed some of the tests he’s had, such as the EKG, chest x-ray and echocardiogram.


As for Clinton, her blood pressure was even lower than Trump’s and both have cholesterol levels in the normal range. Clinton’s calcium score – the higher the number, the higher the risk of heart attack – was zero in contrast to Trump’s 98. In other words, her risk of a heart attack is very low while he’s at moderate risk. Clinton has had a normal breast cancer screening, but there’s no mention of her having colonoscopies. Trump’s doctor reports he last had a normal colonoscopy in 2013.


Still, neither candidate has released anything close to their complete medical records. Releasing a letter or two from one’s personal doctor, as Trump had prior to his Dr Oz appearance, doesn’t come close to releasing complete medical records. Nowhere in Bornstein’s letter about Trump’s health did he mention anything about the bone spurs that supposedly sidelined him during the Vietnam Conflict. Trump, who described sex in the 1980s as his own “personal Vietnam,” must have taken tests for sexually transmitted diseases over the years. Trump reports having been hospitalized once for an appendectomy at age 11, but we haven’t seen those records.


As for Hillary Clinton – who wasn’t involved in the Dr Oz broadcast but whose health status became part of the news cycle when she was diagnosed with pneumonia – where are the records of her healthy child visits and childhood vaccinations? Of the prenatal care, including STD tests, she received when pregnant with Chelsea? In recent years, Clinton has suffered from falls, which could all be due to exhaustion or dehydration, but could also be a sign of an abnormal heart rhythm or other heart condition. And we don’t know why she takes coumadin, a blood thinner.


And does the public need full access to a candidate’s medical records to determine if candidate is healthy enough to serve as Commander in Chief? Or is this just to satisfy our own prurient interests?


What is relevant is whether either candidate has a chronic or life-threatening medical condition that would prevent them from doing their job or would lead to their untimely death while still in office.


We all get the occasional cough or cold. Sick with intestinal flu, Former President George HW Bush famously vomited and collapsed at a state dinner given in his honor at the home of Japanese Prime Minister. It was embarrassing, but he recovered. What I want to know is what Trump’s going to do to avoid developing full-blown diabetes or having a heart attack, and how Clinton’s going to take better care of herself so she doesn’t drive herself to the point of exhaustion.


The conspiracy theories about Clinton’s health are really a demand for transparency, but neither Trump nor Clinton is offering anything close to that. Both candidates have long relationships with their personal physicians. Doctors want to help their patients and may be biased, whether consciously or not, in reporting on their health when so much is at stake.


The best way to give voters the answers they need isn’t a data dump of thousands of pages of medical records. Even then, those records may not be complete and still need to be interpreted in the context of an up-to-date interview and physical exam. Early in the campaign, candidates should submit to examination by objective third party physicians – whether they be former Surgeon Generals or the attending physician for Congress – so that they are all held to the same standards.


We need a system that respects patient privacy, even when those patients are our presidential candidates, while answering voters’ reasonable questions about a candidate’s ability to serve.



Dr Oz"s missed opportunity: scolding Trump for all his bad habits | Celine Gounder

18 Haziran 2014 Çarşamba

Dr. Oz Senate Scolding: His 10 Most Controversial Excess weight Loss Supplements

Yesterday Dr. Mehmet Oz generally admitted just before a Senate subcommittee hearing that a lot of of the claims he can make about fat reduction dietary supplements are not primarily based in reality.


“I can not figure this out, Dr. Oz – I really don’t get why you need to have to say this stuff when you know it’s not real,” complained Senator Claire McCaskill in a hearing prior to the Senate subcommittee on Customer Safety, Item Security and Insurance. “When you have this incredible megaphone, why would you cheapen your display?”


Replied Oz: “I actually do personally believe in the things I talk about on the display. I passionately study them. I recognize that oftentimes they really don’t have the scientific muster to current as fact. However, I would give my audience the exact same suggestions I give my family members, and I have offered my family these merchandise.”


Dr. Oz received a Senate scolding yesterday for his enthusiastic coverage of untested weight loss supplements. (Photo: wiki media)

Senator Claire McCaskill chastised Dr. Oz yesterday for his enthusiastic coverage of untested excess weight loss dietary supplements. (Photograph: public domain)



The bodyweight loss products Dr. Oz is talking about are, of program, the numerous dietary supplements that have attained mega-success soon after a mention on his present, a phenomenon now recognized as “the Oz effect.”


And although he admits they’re “controversial,” he also argues that they’re a needed “crutch” for the two thirds of American grownups now classified as obese.


“If the only message I gave was to consume much less and move far more, which is the most crucial point people require to do, we wouldn’t be very successfully be tackling this challenge, because viewers know these actions and they nonetheless struggle,” he explained. “So we search for resources and crutches for quick-phrase help so folks can jump-start off their applications.”


Even more defending the role of his display, he adds: “I would rather have a conversation about these resources on my stage than in back alleys.”


So what are the fat loss supplements getting Dr. Oz into sizzling water? A rapid rundown:


one. Forskolin: In the hearings, McCaskill brings up Forskulin, reminding Oz that he called it “lightning in a bottle” and “a miracle flower” in an episode of his present this previous January.


What it actually is: A chemical located in the roots of the plant Plectranthus Barbatus that’s been utilised in traditional medication to treat higher blood pressure and heart disorders.


2. FBCx: Oz counters McCaskill with a defense of FBCx, “which is basically a fiber and we know that fiber when taken accurately is a really efficient fat reduction device.”


What it really is: A kind of fiber known as alpha-cyclodextrin that is been used to decrease cholesterol and bind triglycerides. The term FBCx is an abbreviation for “Fat Binding Complexer” and is generally just a branding term.


3. Raspberry Ketones: Dr. Oz has named it: “A number 1 miracle in a bottle to burn up your body fat.”


What it really is: A compound derived from red raspberries that may possibly help regulate adiponectin, a protein that impacts metabolic process.


four. Yakon Syrup: Dr. Oz has termed  it “a metabolism game-changer.”



Dr. Oz Senate Scolding: His 10 Most Controversial Excess weight Loss Supplements